Measuring the Stress Response
By Brandon LaGreca, LAc, MAcOM
*That is an article from the Spring 2023 subject of Fight Stress
For army personnel and first responders, performing underneath demanding situations comes as a part of the job. Quantifying how stress impacts the person is an evolving science. This text explores the historical past of assessments that consider the well being of the vagus nerve, a part of the parasympathetic nervous system, or measure the discharge of stress hormones. To greatest perceive one’s resilience to demanding conditions, you will need to doc these results with confirmed metrics.
Earlier than lab testing, holistic healthcare suppliers assessed stress resilience in quite a lot of intelligent methods, a number of of which have been centered on the well being and performance of the adrenal glands. One instance is Ragland’s take a look at. This includes taking a affected person’s blood stress after a number of minutes, whereas the affected person lies in a relaxed state, adopted by a second measurement taken because the affected person rises to face. The sudden change of place and consequent have to rapidly get blood to the top is regarded as influenced by adrenal hormones. Lightheadedness upon rising (orthostatic hypotension) was thought of an indication of adrenal insufficiency.
A technique taught inside naturopathic drugs to evaluate vagal tone, and by extension the resilience of the parasympathetic nervous system, is the analysis of palatal rise. The levator veli palatini muscle, accountable for the rising and falling of the oral palate, is instantly innervated by the vagus nerve. Having a affected person stick out the tongue and say “aah” (extra typically used to verify the well being of the tonsils) is a window to look at the evenness of how the palate seems and the way rapidly it strikes. Asymmetry and sluggish rising of the palate is taken into account an indication of poor vagal tone.
How exact these exams are at addressing autonomic nervous system well being is debatable. Such strategies shaped the spine of guide analysis by old-school practitioners, who both didn’t have entry to laboratory evaluation or have been working towards earlier than the chemical evaluation of hormone well being was out there.
Early Nineteen Sixties analysis in psychophysiology relied on a number of strategies of quantifying the stress response, together with measuring modifications in coronary heart charge, respiration, and electrodermal response (resembling with polygraph machines to gauge the refined stress markers which will point out that an individual is mendacity).1
By the Nineteen Seventies, coronary heart charge variability (HRV) entered the scene, providing a brand new degree of sophistication by measuring the minute however wholesome change (variability) within the interval between every heartbeat as a marker of stress resilience and optimum vagal tone.2
With vital refinement to the know-how over the previous few a long time, HRV has turn out to be the dominant participant within the rising science of biofeedback, permitting the person to exactly monitor the stress and leisure response in actual time. The well being of the parasympathetic nervous system may be learn like an open ebook within the coronary heart’s variability, with HRV appearing as an specific indicator of vagal tone. The HeartMath Institute is on the forefront of HRV testing, churning out analysis and scaling HRV-measuring know-how in order that exact and inexpensive units are actually out there to shoppers.3
In an outpatient setting, typical drugs favors mind imaging by useful MRI (fMRI) or single-photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) scans to visualise central nervous system well being, whereas bloodwork is the usual for figuring out hormone ranges. These strategies are well-validated for prognosis, however they’ve flaws. One drawback with utilizing bloodwork to evaluate hormone ranges is that hormones journey certain to proteins when circulating within the bloodstream. Solely by extrapolation can energetic ranges of hormone ranges be assessed, if in any respect.
To measure energetic or free ranges of cortisol, sampling saliva is a technique most popular by holistic healthcare suppliers. After I started personal apply, I ordered cortisol panels that required the affected person to gather a saliva pattern (spit in a tube) 4 occasions a day to graph the rhythm of cortisol launch. Cortisol is highest within the morning, peaks shortly after rising, slopes downward by the day, and is lowest at evening as melatonin rises and the physique prepares for slumber.
In these early days of cortisol testing, a four-point saliva panel was a sport changer. Testing a affected person with a prognosis of persistent fatigue typically revealed a flatlined cortisol rhythm, with a complete cortisol degree under common. This led to the then-vogue prognosis of adrenal insufficiency (or adrenal fatigue).
One other frequent sample noticed is an inversion, whereby cortisol is low within the morning and spikes within the night. This illustrates the basic “wired-and-tired” affected person who experiences nonrestorative sleep—waking drained and needing stimulants (caffeine) to get going within the morning, solely to seek out themselves “jacked up” and unable to wind down on the finish of the day (evidenced by the night spike in cortisol).
These assessments have been handy and directed profitable medical interventions, however they weren’t probably the most exact when it comes to what is going on on the degree of mobile human physiology. The true medical image grew to become clear with the inclusion of urine testing to measure metabolized ranges of hormones resembling cortisol, estrogen, and progesterone. Launched by the lab Precision Analytical, the dried urine take a look at for complete hormones, or DUTCH take a look at, makes use of 4 urine samples taken all through the day to derive a day by day cortisol rhythm whereas sussing out the quantity of metabolized hormones that cross by the kidneys to be excreted.
Measuring cortisone (cortisol deactivated within the colon, kidneys, and salivary glands) along with cortisol led to an essential medical discovery. Some sufferers beforehand recognized as having adrenal insufficiency turned out to be excreting excessive ranges of cortisol metabolites. It wasn’t a difficulty of an absence of cortisol, somewhat, there was an absence of communication between the mind and glands to correctly regulate hormone ranges. This led to the extra exact prognosis of HPA-axis dysfunction, denoting the disharmony inherent from chronically elevated ranges of cortisol that downregulate signaling hormones within the mind.
These sufferers have been producing adrenal hormones, generally excessively, however the internet impact on the physique was a decreased motion of these hormones on the applicable websites. That is analogous to the vigorous manufacturing of insulin, but lack of mobile response to shuttle sugar into the cells in sufferers with kind 2 diabetes.
Metabolized hormone ranges are an essential piece of the puzzle, however as a result of saliva was nonetheless related to evaluate adrenal resilience, Precision Analytical added one other metric, utilizing 4 saliva samples to derive what is called cortisol awakening response (CAR).
Measuring CAR includes taking three saliva samples inside the first 60 minutes of rising to see how vigorously and appropriately cortisol surges and the way that impact is maintained throughout the preliminary timeframe of waking. Analysis suggests testing CAR is a clinically related evaluation of adrenal well being.4,5
The rhythm of cortisol launch is predictive of stress resilience. The door swings the opposite manner too, with a dysregulated cortisol rhythm suggestive of illness. One examine indicated an irregular or flattened cortisol rhythm is predictive of early mortality from breast most cancers.6 
Testing cortisol may also function a proxy to evaluate potential environmental stressors. One paper confirmed how extended publicity to fluorescent lamps appreciably lowered cortisol ranges. Readers of my first ebook, Most cancers and EMF Radiation: The best way to Defend Your self from the Silent Carcinogen of Electropollution, is not going to be shocked by this revelation, given the detrimental electromagnetic discipline emitted by fluorescent lights.7
The reverse has been studied. Early morning shiny mild publicity raises cortisol to wholesome ranges, whereas alterations to circadian rhythm by shift work or daylight-saving time have an effect on optimum cortisol output.8,9
An essential level to make at this juncture is that testing guides remedy within the context of a affected person’s general well being. There isn’t any one-size-fits-all method, and smart holistic healthcare suppliers are cautious to pursue remedies that tweak hormones primarily based on lab outcomes alone.
Hormesis reigns supreme with hormone stability. An excessive amount of cortisol is as problematic as too little. Elevated norepinephrine is essential to survival when the sympathetic nervous system is activated, however chronically excessive ranges can result in hormonal chaos.
It’s attainable to “bio-hack” these hormones with chemical therapies, from amino acids to pharmaceuticals. Beta blockers will blunt the results of elevated norepinephrine at the price of unintended effects inherent from altering regular human biochemistry.10 For cortisol, phosphatidylserine lowers elevated ranges and hydrocortisone replaces and suppresses output.11
These substances all have their place and may be essential instruments, supplied that dependency doesn’t ensue from their use. That is very true of hydrocortisone, as doses above physiological limits launched by the adrenal glands trigger a profound downregulation of the physique’s skill to provide cortisol. For that reason, excessive doses of steroid medication are prescribed with a gradual tapering of dosage over a number of days (if not weeks). Failure to take action could result in the iatrogenic model of Addison’s illness when the adrenal glands fail to rebound following pharmaceutical suppression.
Natural drugs provides a smart method to managing hormone imbalances, not as a result of nature’s pharmacy is inherently protected (although typically it’s), however as a result of many herbs that tackle hormone issues are normalizing, which means they will sign the mind to both increase or decrease hormone ranges relying on want. These responses happen inside the physique’s design and don’t drive biochemical reactions like a drug does. To study extra concerning the protected use of adaptogenic herbs, seek the advice of a licensed healthcare supplier educated in useful or integrative drugs.
Parts of this text have been excerpted from Brandon’s ebook, Most cancers, Stress & Mindset: Focusing the Thoughts to Empower Therapeutic and Resilience, out there on his web site BrandonLaGreca.com and thru on-line retailers.
References
1. Stern, John A. “Towards a Definition of Psychophysiology.” Psychophysiology 1, no. 1 (1964): 90–91. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1469-8986.1964.tb02626.x.
2. Berntson, Gary G., J. Thomas Greater, Dwain L. Eckberg, Paul Grossman, Peter G. Kaufmann, Marek Malik, Haikady N. Nagaraja, et al. “Coronary heart Charge Variability: Origins, Strategies, and Interpretive Caveats.” Psychophysiology 34, no. 6 (1997): 623–48. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1469-8986.1997.tb02140.x.
3. McCraty, Rollin, Bob Barrios-Choplin, Deborah Rozman, Mike Atkinson, and Alan D. Watkins. “The Influence of a New Emotional Self-Administration Program on Stress, Feelings, Coronary heart Charge Variability, DHEA and Cortisol.” Integrative Physiological and Behavioral Science 33, no. 2 (April 1, 1998): 151–70. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02688660.
4. Clow, Angela, Frank Hucklebridge, Tobias Stalder, Phil Evans, and Lisa Thorn. “The Cortisol Awakening Response: Greater than a Measure of HPA Axis Operate.” Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Critiques, Psychophysiological Biomarkers of Well being, 35, no. 1 (September 1, 2010): 97–103. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neubiorev.2009.12.011.
5. Fries, Eva, Lucia Dettenborn, and Clemens Kirschbaum. “The Cortisol Awakening Response (CAR): Information and Future Instructions.” Worldwide Journal of Psychophysiology, 72, no. 1 (April 1, 2009): 67–73. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijpsycho.2008.03.014.
6. Sephton, Sandra E., Robert M. Sapolsky, Helena C. Kraemer, and David Spiegel. “Diurnal Cortisol Rhythm as a Predictor of Breast Most cancers Survival.” JNCI: Journal of the Nationwide Most cancers Institute 92, no. 12 (June 21, 2000): 994–1000. https://doi.org/10.1093/jnci/92.12.994.
7. Jung, Christopher M., Sat Bir S. Khalsa, Frank A. J. L. Scheer, Christian Cajochen, Steven W. Lockley, Charles A. Czeisler, and Kenneth P. Wright. “Acute Results of Vibrant Gentle Publicity on Cortisol Ranges.” Journal of Organic Rhythms 25, no. 3 (Might 19, 2010): 208–16. https://doi.org/10.1177/0748730410368413.
8. Hadlow, Narelle C., Suzanne Brown, Robert Wardrop, and David Henley. “The Results of Season, Daylight Saving and Time of Dawn on Serum Cortisol in a Massive Inhabitants.” Chronobiology Worldwide 31, no. 2 (March 1, 2014): 243–51. https://doi.org/10.3109/07420528.2013.844162.
9. Thorn, L., F. Hucklebridge, A. Esgate, P. Evans, and A. Clow. “The Impact of Daybreak Simulation on the Cortisol Response to Awakening in Wholesome Individuals.” Psychoneuroendocrinology 29, no. 7 (August 1, 2004): 925–30. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.psyneuen.2003.08.005.
10. Fitzgerald, Paul J. “Beta Blockers, Norepinephrine, and Most cancers: An Epidemiological Viewpoint.” Medical Epidemiology 4 (2012): 151–56. https://doi.org/10.2147/CLEP.S33695.
11. Benton, D., R.T. Donohoe, B. Sillance, and S. Nabb. “The Affect of Phosphatidylserine Supplementation on Temper and Coronary heart Charge When Confronted with an Acute Stressor.” Dietary Neuroscience 4, no. 3 (January 1, 2001): 169–78. https://doi.org/10.1080/1028415X.2001.11747360.